If We Are Witnessing the Downfall of the Cult of Attacking Play, Let’s Savour What It Created.
The Journey of a Cult can be defined by specific steps.
1. The Core Concept
A charismatic leader or leaders introduce an innovative concept that promises a solution for struggling players.
Thus we find ourselves. They’re getting ready to challenge the establishment in Australia. Tensions are rising. Signs of trouble appear from the sidelines. An isolated player, naked, nervous, the phrase ATTACKING MINDSET displayed prominently as a statement, has come staggering from the field and is taken aside under a blanket towards an inconclusive loan stint in county cricket.
Do you recall the start, when the world was still young? The days of Bazball 1.0, of pure instinct.
2. The Honeymoon Phase
Cult leaders promise a fresh beginning, hope for a future, support, success among a group who all believe in the big idea.
What was this thing back then? Players celebrating basking in glory. Ink. Forearms. Jawlines. Elite male wellness energy. Of course, The team insist Bazball doesn’t actually exist, ironically as it’s denied, what exactly did I just watch?
Yet it’s clear what it is. It’s the batsman attempting a move so unconventional it’s beyond belief. It’s the adrenaline of the captain in his final form, a look that says: pensive Nordic god, strong features, hair woven from beaver hide, truly contemporary you almost imagine to notice and notice he’s fielding at mid-off bare-chested embracing nature.
It’s the opener often seen to talk in press conferences, appearing as a joyful figure in a waistcoat, expressing thoughts like we are actively deconstructing the orange. And yes, the energy, for a significant period, was uplifting.
3. A New Life
Development stage. Togetherness strengthened by rote learning of key phrases. These beliefs are often illogical as a test of “true belief”.
Is it just me? The reaction, the anger, the sense of betrayal after the first Ashes Test defeat seems too strong, too much. The batting collapsed on the field, as history shows. They were torn apart defensively during a brief period as the bowling and captaincy fell apart, outplayed by the batsman playing aggressively but smarter, adaptive to conditions, a man playing with aura.
Currently, we see the pile-on, the frustration, the perception of the team as a kind of abomination. The opinion suggests that England don’t just need to lose, they need to lose righteously, to be cleansed, flame-throwered, defeated through sheer skill of the pace attack, the simple basics of the bowler, out there celebrating achievements humbly as if receiving a rewarding prize. What impact will this have?
4. Hate Bonding
Issues emerge from failures in the plan. However, faults are ignored. It begins to thrive on hatred of the outside world.
In truth, approaching from the second Test, we have now reached a critical juncture in the story of this approach. They might succeed in Brisbane with bold tactics. Probably, they could lose just as quickly. And if they do lose it seems we may see the death cult phase.
Before that happens, there are two things worth saying about this. More than two years ago, back in those heady early days, of light and heat, I wrote an article calling it a phenomenon. People were very angry, which proved the point as it’s known how to confirm that it’s not a closed group is when its acolytes react defensively denying scrutiny of its truths.
Recent events lately are fascinating. It seems that hating Bazball has now become the cult. We have a uniformly angry internet, angry English pundits, images of frustrated supporters abroad missing out on play, like a room full of investors demanding recourse.
Meanwhile, exists the larger scene of Australia’s more nuanced ingrained annoyance with the aggressive tourists, stating, hey, that thing you love and have fostered and nurtured to distinguish yourselves culturally from us, it’s just a joke ultimately.
Here lies the truth. All movements are similar. The approach was a phenomenon as the game has its own culture. Or rather, the team has long been exclusive, a circle, a private event, an insular community with two hundred years of tradition and mystery defining it. Historically, this was a place where power and access are hoarded. It’s the imperial sport of England, the early image-makers. And notably, the country is a phenomenon, a system of unknown levels, a royal family remains.
The players have been sealed up in this system from a young age. Seeking change, to build a better atmosphere, they are mirroring their past, forming a new circle, an exclusive group, but doing it this time with a modern squad and a mentor who wants you to be yourself as long as yourself is quite a lot like myself.
Stay present. Embrace challenges. However much you change, you remain stuck.
Reflecting on this, now is the time to have some sympathy for the approach, to recognize its positives, which are significant. What is Bazball? Encouraging expression. Challenging orthodoxies. Batting aggressively|Attacking with